B. F. married Sarah Jane King ca. 1870. They were the parents of seven children: Fred McReynolds, born 31 June 1871 in Worth County, MO Ava McReynolds, born 18 Sep 1872 in Worth County, MO Myrtle McReynolds, born ca. 1874-76. died as a child Elmer McReynolds, born 20 Mar 1878 in Worth County, MO Lola McReynolds, born Nov 1880 in Worth County, MO Walter McReynolds, born March 1883 in Barton County, MO Bertha McReynolds, born 10 Aug 1886 in Barton County, MO Ava married Louis Biersmith Elmer Married Minne Triplett Lola married Boyd Hartman Walter never married Bertha married William Bales Sarah Jane "Jennie" King McReynolds died 21 December 1891 and was buried at McKill Cemetery.

After his first wife died in 1891, B. F. married Mary Hoagland in Nevada, Vernon County, MO on December 29, 1892. She had been born in September 1872 in Indiana. B. F. and Mary were the parents of two children and lived at Bronaugh.: Leona McReynolds was born 8 October 1893 Mamie McReynolds, was born in October 1894. Leona McReynolds Leona McReynolds was the valedictorian of Nevada High School in 1914. She married Arthur Kresse on 5 Nov 1915 in Johnson County, KS. Lucille Marshall wrote that "Both Aunt Leona and her husband were Baptist ministers. I believer that Aunt Leona was the first female minister ordained by William Jewell. The college is located in Liberty, MO. Uncle Dick later became a teacher in the K. C. MO schools. He taught English at Northeast High School in 1928. Mamie McReynolds married Jerry Wilhite who later joined the bank with his father in law.